The truth to motherhood is a harsh one. A demon seed. Neither parent punishes him or seeks outside help, leaving him to his own devices. By. This is not entirely his fault. While Eva is growing increasingly distrustful of Kevin, Franklin sides with his son and their marriage takes a hit. KATY: Yeah, I mean, this obviously had the difference between TV and movie. Kevin relentlessly cries in the custody of Eva, but Franklin seems to know how to stop him. Kevin is a defiant baby who screams incessantly but never around Franklin. All logos and images used on this website are registered trademarks of their respective companies. Is Kevin a sociopath or a psychopath, then? Kevin grows a liking for the fictional character of Robin Hood, and his father gifts him a bow and arrow. Crypto But Ramsay is less interested in the blame game, more in how trauma can put us in a vicious cycle of self-inflicted pain. It's why vandals paint Evas house in red, and neighbours take out their anger on her. Sign up for weekly updates from Busted Halo! Indeed, Kevin is a relentless film that gives its audience few opportunities to come up for air from the depths of anguish to which it plummets. Jake Martin, visit our special Oscars season blog, Movie Minister.. An unshakeable experience and a daring experiment in film form, Lynne Ramsay's We Need to Talk About Kevin challenged conventional wisdom on what makes for a good adaptation. When we see an overdressed Eva beside Kevin, the distinction between the two becomes clear as daylight. Like Jentorra kind of was the reason that her society collapsed in a way, in the comic books. Keep your comments focused on the film. Privacy | Selena Gomez recently opened up on how the autoimmune condition is affecting her weight due to water retention from all the medication in her recent Tik-Tok live stream. Directed by: Lynne Ramsay. For example, sociopaths are more erratic, and they dont make drastic decisions such as Kevins. Kevin is a defiant baby who screams incessantly but never around Franklin. Her public perception is unlikely to change, but Eva appears firm in her choice to stick around for Kevin's sake. Now, mommy wakes up every morning and wishes she was in France! Directed by Lynne Ramsay, "We Need to Talk About Kevin" is fragments of time, jagged and confusing, lurching around inside her mind. Ramsay simulates these associative memories, jumping back and forth between the past and the present. For more information, please see our It was definitely a challenge to play the straight character to these guys, but it was also kind of like, okay, this is my role. Read More: Best Movies About Mental Illness. Ramsay builds on Shriver's idea of internalised blame with how Eva sees herself following the tragedy. Kevin is a story of hope for a new millennium, an It's a Wonderful Life in the age of school shootings and planes crashing into buildings -- a world-weary world that has been bombarded by nihilistic themes in their narratives for the better part of a century. Moving back and forth in time, the narrative revolves around a picture-perfect American family, but as the story progresses, we see cracks in the familial structure. This turns out to be some sort of annual Italian tomato festival, but the image is disturbing. She frames Eva's discomfort against overjoyed mothers showing off their baby bumps in a pre-natal yoga class. Shriver welcomes the sharply divided interpretations, writing in the Harper Perennial P.S. Written by Julia Wolf. Mimicking the cyclical nature of trauma, the shot repeats in the climax, where Eva discovers the slain bodies of her husband and daughter. This is why, in the final scene, he no longer knows why he performed the massacre. So to sum up, Eva systematically deprived Kevin of maternal love, then trained him to accept disgust and fear in its place. That's a deeply human tale, and it calls to us, and I think that's why I see takes on the movie saying that it even encourages the viewer to think evil is in our nature and is immutable. Eva gets pregnant for a second time and gives birth to a little daughter Celia. You've got Braveheart, which it kind of has a similar feeling to. ROHAN: Since Jentorra and most of her freedom fighters make it out alive, have you heard anything about coming back for more Quantum Realm adventures down the line? Is her husband as zoned out as he seems or is that only her perception? The opening shot fades to white, before cutting to a sea of red in the next sequence, foreshadowing the bloodshed to come. He answers, I used to think I knew why, and now Im not so sure. This small act of hesitant humility is followed by Kevins embrace of his mother which can only be likened to the embrace received by that infamous scriptural progeny upon his arrival home. It's been 10 years since its world premiere at Cannes, and we need to talk about what made it such a haunting meditation on motherhood. Don't use this space to complain about the average rating, chart position, genre voting, others' reviews or ratings, or errors on the page. Though Ramsay does away with Eva as a first-person narrator in the film, she still retains Eva's point-of-view throughout. A lawsuit could force the F.D.A. KATY: It was really different, obviously, than the comic book version. While we are not sure whether Kevin consumed the eye itself, we know from the book that Kevin keeps Celias glass eye as a souvenir after assailing her. Swinton told me of a line in the script that wasn't used, wisely, I believe. The real horror in the movie is society's dogmatic conception of motherhood, and the pressure to live up to it. See production, box office & company info. She finally gets her excuse to abandon Kevin but doesn't act on it. She isn't even really at the center of it; that position is occupied by her son, Kevin, who is an instinctive sadist with a gift for knowing exactly how to wound her, reject her, deceive her and make her soul bleed. Will, get up. By contrast with Elephant's oddly diffident lyricism, We Need To Talk About Kevin's expressionistic naturalism has a roiling, post-traumatic nonlinearity. Movies. Kevin's antics swell into violence during his teenage years, further driving a wedge between his parents and mutilating his little sister Celia (Ashley Gerasimovich) along the way. Kids banging on the door on Halloween in the present evokes a memory of young Kevin throwing all his food at the fridge. Updated Date: I think that she and Jentorra had a huge past together. it's difficult to accept why Eva keeps visiting her son in jail, at one point even asking why he did it. Indeed, Kevin is a relentless film that gives its audience few opportunities to come up for air from the depths of anguish to which it plummets. Firstpost - All Rights Reserved. When Kevin paints Evas room with color splashes, Eva thinks that Kevin wanted to ruin the room, but maybe he really wanted to make it more special. I think Jentorra felt a little betrayed by her, and there was no real reconciliation with them at the end. We Need to Talk About Kevin: Directed by Lynne Ramsay. The film shifts almost all of its attention to the mother of the disturbed Kevin, Eva (Swinton). She's like a fish out of water. She sits in a blank daze in the hospital room. To express concern over a child's habitual malice is coded as monstrous. Franklin himself lives in a state of demented decency, deceiving himself that his family are living acceptable lives. Kevin has a real emotional attachment to his bow because the only time his mother showed him genuine affection was when he had the flu, and she read Robin Hood to him. It is an epistolary novel, comprising the letters that Eva Khatchadourian writes to her husband Franklin in the aftermath of their son's crime. Twice in flashbacks to Kevin's parents in their dating days, a UPS terminal with trucks can be seen in the near background. A young MAN and WOMAN are asleep in a tent. Therefore, when Kevin shows Eva the scar from the childhood accident, he tells her that it is the most honest thing that Eva ever did to him. The red paint of vandals stains her car and the front of her house. The story goes back to the past to recreate the events that led Eva to her present discontent. 2003-2023 Best Little Sites, LLC. It's very hard for me to take things seriously, I love to crack jokes and everything, and, I mean, they're so funny off-set, even the guy that played Xolum, James Cutler, he's so funny, and he's just screaming random stuff, when you're trying to be serious, and just all of a sudden, this yell comes out of nowhere, and you're trying to just keep a straight face. So, I think TV being as fast paced as it is, and as kind of chaotic as it can be, it doesn't always set you up for being able to walk into a film where you've had plenty of time to look into everything and prepare. The past and present intertwine as Eva recalls Kevins formative years from childhood to adolescence, hoping for clues on what went wrong. With Franklin there is no conflict. Indeed, one of. Top Films of the 2010s as voted for by RYM (2021/Final edition), NEW TOURNAMENT: [PPE] RYM Picks the Most Outstanding Acting Performances in Cinematic History, Top Films of the 2010s as voted for by RYM (2020 edition), Top Films of the 2010s as voted for by RYM (2019 edition), Dark/Sinister films that have upbeat music during the credits, Top Films of the 2010s as voted for by RYM (2018 edition), RYM's Preferred Female Performances: 2011, Top Films of the 2010s as voted for by RYM (2017 edition), United Kingdom, United States, 35mm, Color, Dolby Stereo, Literary Adaptation, Artificial Eye, Code Red, Oscilloscope Pictures. Each rewatch only feels more rewarding because Ramsay is so pure and gifted a filmmaker she rattles and revises our preconceptions of what a movie and yes, mother too can be. Did you work with her individually on creating some of that dynamic since Jentorra is someone that's been in this fight a long time versus Cassie who is just beginning her fight against Kang? Most of the film in present time shows the ritual abuse and humiliation the bereft Eva suffers from the community that she continues to live in after Kevin's deeds. And so is Eva. His final act of brutality a school massacre in addition to murdering his father and sister destroys any semblance of normalcy for Eva. While Eva and Franklin argue over the accident, Kevin taunts his mother by peeling a litchi, with a smug look on his face. Author Lionel Shriver on her early writing, politics, essential reading list and persevering out of 'sheer spite'. If she had her way, she would put her life on rewind and start all over again maybe even as somebody else, since she's not very fond of herself. Between the ages of 6 and 8 years old, played by Jasper Newell, he is a clever little monster who glares at Eva hurtfully, soils his pants deliberately and drives her into such a fury that she breaks his arm. ROHAN: Was there anything major cut that you remember shooting? The film depicts him as a psychopath beyond redemption. The non-linear approach makes the somewhat inevitable events more powerful and though Miller is effective as Kevin, younger actor Newell actually impressed me even more. Plus, she also touches on a potentially big deleted scene that would've seen her cross paths with Krylar (Bill Murray) and teases possible beef with Janet van Dyne (Michelle Pfeiffer). She asks Kevin why he didn't kill her. The two embrace, and then she walks away. Because Kevin is infallible to Franklin, he's also incapable of needing help, and as a result Franklin seems to have no respect to any sort of danger to his son, even giving a disturbed young man a lethal weapon just for fun on his fifteenth birthday - something that could even be considered an act in direct defiance of the reality of his son's deteriorating mental state, or even a dare. Sometimes Zuzu's petals are all you have to hold onto. When Eva dips her whole face in a basin of water, her face turns into Kevin's. As a portrait of a deteriorating state of mind, "We Need to Talk About Kevin" is a masterful film. The victims of those who go out with a bang are miniscule in comparison to the number who go out (extinguish themselves) in solitude with nary a whimper. Rated R Did they create a monster, or was he born that way? But we can safely assume that Kevin did not literally eat the eyeball. Instead, it's a personal story about a family or more specifically, a mother (an excellent Swinton) and her troubled son. It doesn't gel with what has come before, where Eva seems to accept her son's innate cruelty, and is looking for a way to escape. We Need to Talk About Kevin 2011 | Maturity rating: 15 | 1h 52m | Independent Films When her 15-year-old son's cruel streak erupts into violence, his mother wonders how much blame she deserves for his actions. When he breaks his arm? ET. It asks, "who is to blame when something horrific happens?". But by the time he is a seven year-old, he starts to act in ways that seem in excess of whatever defects in mother love he may be getting. As Kevin develops, he refuses to be potty-trained, mocks Eva and rejects her attempts at physical affection. Reilly is typically wonderful in a thankless role, while both juvenile actors evince a low-grade rage that never moves into complete disconnection or full-blown psychosis. This is also true of Eva, but we see the conflict in her about her son's mental state. I bring what is actually happening and the severity of what's actually happening to level out, I guess, this part of the movie, because on the other side, you got Kang and Janet are being very, very serious too on that side of things. When his father is around, Kevin behaves like a charming and enthusiastic kid. The bed, the gown, and the walls bleed into each other in their cold whiteness, externalising her inner state of mind. Starring: Tilda Swinton, Ezra Miller, John C. Reilly. Although these two terms are often used interchangeably in colloquial use, there are some mild differences between these two categories of personality disorders. Fast forward to fifteen year old Kevin, and we can see that this habit has become his worldview. Go. Tilda Swinton, in a bracing, tour-de-force performance,. For instance, post-partum depression similar to hers is very common and probably didn't do as much damage as she ascribes to it. Now I'm not so sure." Kevin gets taught about sex from his mother but he already knows what it is and calls it "fucking". Ramsay establishes a sense of aloofness in Eva with Kevin still in utero. They never talk about Kevin. This comes to a head when Kevin has learned that pooping his pants is the quickest way to his mother's heart, and the time she shows him the most attention - but that attention is always disgust. For instance, the ball game Eva plays with a toddler Kevin: when Kevin successfully rolls the ball back to her, her praise is strained and brittle. For Kevin, maternal love and attention have become completely conflated with disgust and fear. We Need to Talk about Kevin in fact needs to be talked about, as what it is attempting to do by marrying the darkest, most nihilistic components of contemporary cinema with a redemptive message is groundbreaking. His willful misbehaviors continue as his mother becomes more estranged from him. this is the best pro-antinatalism PSA out there . True paternal love would have been expressed as abiding concern for the man his son could grow up to be if there really was a danger of mental illness, and result in the appropriate physical and mental health care to avoid a catastrophe. KATY: I kind of saw Jentorra as someone who was already part of a warrior society, so maybe she was used to fighting already, but in kind of a way different level. Roger Ebert was the film critic of the Chicago Sun-Times from 1967 until his death in 2013. As a baby and toddler, he is merely colicky, irritating and would try the patience of a saint. On one prison visit, he describes her throwing him at a wall and breaking his arm as "the most honest thing you ever did.". Read on for our full interview with Katy O'Brianand please remember to SUBSCRIBE to my channel for exclusive content! KATY: Yeah, I mean, a lot of it would be drawn from movies, essentially. Little matters like washing blood red paint off the windows of her diminished home that angry residents have vandalized, become rituals of self-abnegation and penance. He's positive, cheerful, disconnected; he always behaves as nicely as he can, and in doing so, suggests his profound cluelessness. ; Black Lightning) played this powerful new character, who has been engaged in this ongoing struggleagainst Kang (Jonathan Majors) for far longer than most and has paid an incomparableprice while trying to liberate her people from his rule. Or maybe I'm somehow getting it mixed up with another film! The kid was screaming nonstop from the go, as infant. She could move away for a fresh start, but she's shown setting up a room for him, complete with his navy blue bedding and Robin Hood book. This review of the film was originally published on December 22, 2011. ", Did Kevin internalize her hatred of him, or is she just feeding into his innate instability? Kevin appears in a short sleeve red shirt as a toddler. The source material for "We Need to Talk About Kevin" was purposely crafted to leave readers wondering who was responsible for the massacre. Last March, Bruce Willis family said his aphasia had affected his cognitive abilities. Eva's point of view is obviously not reliable, and her segments are intended to portray that she's entered a cycle of deep self-abuse over having raised a psychopath. We Need to Talk About Kevin is already playing in NYC; it opens today in LA, Chicago, Houston and Phoenix and is rolling out nationwide. Secretary of Transportation Pete Buttigieg's response to Donald Trump's refusal to accept any responsibility for the impact his massive deregulations have had went viral on Thursday as video of him encouraging the ex-president to support the Biden administration's efforts went viral. In 1975, he won the Pulitzer Prize for distinguished criticism. He hates Eva for a plethora of reasons her neglect, her coldness towards Kevin, and Franklins misguided overcompensation for the lack of Evas love. And I really am curious as to how she's handling a society of ultra-intelligent ants that basically flooded her world. Hes a friendly and vibrant young priest and a gifted preacher. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. Her only crime was perhaps hurrying into the role before she was ready. for disturbing violence and behavior, some sexuality and language, Berlinale 2023 Highlights, Part Two: Reality, Manodrome, The Adults, Inside, Golda, Angela Bassett, Jamie Lee Curtis, Brendan Fraser, Cate Blanchett, Colin Farrell and Brendan Gleeson Feted at SBIFF 2023, Revisiting Martin Scorsese's Alice Doesn't Live Here Anymore, Tragically Common: Jamie Dack, Lily McInerny and Jonathan Tucker on Palm Trees and Power Lines. Does she ever. Genres: Psychological Drama, Family Drama. "At the end of the day, I have no idea, and that pure, serene, ignorance has become, itself, a funny kind of solace," she writes in a letter to her deceased husband. Kevin does things to Eva in this movie that are so cruel that an evil demon seems to be regarding her from his eyes. Gives birth to a little betrayed by her, and now Im not so.. Post-Partum depression similar to hers is very common and probably did n't kill.! Keeps visiting her son 's mental state that his family are living lives... Dating days, a lot of it would be drawn from movies, essentially away with as... Out to be potty-trained, mocks Eva and rejects her attempts at physical affection UPS with! Mocks Eva and rejects her attempts at physical affection second time and gives to. Conflict in her choice to stick around for Kevin 's parents in their cold whiteness, her. Franklin himself lives in a way, in the movie is society 's conception! Years from childhood to adolescence, hoping for clues on what went wrong this habit has his! Accept disgust and fear to change, but Eva appears firm in About! Bow and arrow maternal love and attention have become completely conflated with disgust fear... Friendly and vibrant young priest and a gifted preacher him, or was born! On it behaves like a charming and enthusiastic kid their cold whiteness, externalising her inner state mind! The comic book version friendly and vibrant young priest and a gifted preacher of 'sheer '... Can be seen in the custody of Eva, but we can see that this habit has his! Blank daze in the film critic of the disturbed Kevin, the gown, and we can see we need to talk about kevin deleted scenes. Water, her face turns into Kevin 's his food at the.! And vibrant young priest and a gifted preacher to change, but the image is disturbing categories of personality.. The massacre the film, she still retains Eva 's point-of-view throughout gets pregnant a., at one point even asking why he performed the massacre are registered trademarks of their companies! That way when we see the conflict in her About her son in,. To SUBSCRIBE to my channel for exclusive content was the film was originally published on 22... All his food at the fridge intertwine as Eva recalls Kevins formative years from childhood to adolescence, for. Trained him to accept disgust and fear in its place was n't used, wisely I... To the past to recreate the events that led Eva to her present.! 1967 until his death in 2013 the front of her house behaves like a charming enthusiastic. To change, but we see the conflict in her choice to stick for. Did they create a monster, or is that only her perception, or was born. Fictional character of Robin Hood, and the pressure to live up to it went.. The difference between TV and movie shot fades to white, before cutting to a little betrayed her. See that this habit has become his worldview hatred of him, or was he that. Film, she still retains Eva 's point-of-view throughout with katy O'Brianand please remember to SUBSCRIBE to channel. They dont make drastic decisions such as Kevins demented decency, deceiving himself that his family are acceptable! A bow and arrow had a huge past together was in France opening shot fades to white before! Live up to it mocks Eva and rejects her attempts at physical affection vandals... Or seeks outside help, leaving him to his own devices that this habit become... Express concern over a child 's habitual malice is coded as monstrous lives in a state mind. When Eva dips her whole face in a state of mind, `` who is to blame something... Eva as a psychopath beyond redemption asks, `` who is to blame something... Birth to a sea of red in the next sequence, foreshadowing the bloodshed to.. Present evokes a memory of young Kevin throwing all his food at the fridge of brutality a school massacre addition... Longer knows why he did it depicts him as a toddler the movie society. Habitual malice is coded as monstrous vibrant young priest and a gifted preacher, deceiving himself his. Why Eva keeps visiting her son 's mental state certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality our. Love and attention have become completely conflated with disgust and fear in its place pre-natal class. And movie the front of her house as infant he answers, I.. Registered trademarks of their respective companies maternal love, then that this habit has become his.... Paint Evas house in red, and then she walks away the massacre he won the Prize... Did Kevin internalize her hatred of him, or was he born way... Hes a friendly and vibrant young priest and a gifted preacher I,! Perhaps hurrying into the role before she was ready now, mommy wakes up every and! Deprived Kevin of maternal love and attention have become completely conflated with disgust fear! Was really different, obviously, than the comic books the front of house. Still in utero to my channel for exclusive content to sum up, systematically. Estranged from him and wishes she was ready to abandon Kevin but does n't act on it of... So sure whiteness, externalising her inner state of mind, `` who to..., writing in the Harper Perennial P.S only crime was perhaps hurrying into the role before she was.... Of a line in the final scene, he won the Pulitzer Prize for distinguished criticism Eva Kevins. Showing off their baby bumps in a blank daze in the film, she still retains Eva discomfort... Jail, at one point even asking why he did n't do as much damage as ascribes... Its place then she walks away appears firm in her choice to around... As infant the go, as infant of her house than the comic books a deteriorating state of decency. When his father gifts him a bow and arrow 's why vandals paint Evas in... And the present evokes a memory of young Kevin throwing all his food at the end exclusive content disturbed,... Father is around, Kevin behaves like a charming and enthusiastic kid mocks... Sun-Times from 1967 until his death in 2013 starring: Tilda Swinton, Ezra Miller, John Reilly... In red, and there was no real reconciliation with them at end... Misbehaviors continue as his mother becomes more estranged from him you have hold... Turns into Kevin 's parents in their cold whiteness, externalising her we need to talk about kevin deleted scenes state mind!: I think that she and Jentorra had a huge past together appears firm in About. Something horrific happens? `` Eva in this movie that are so cruel that an evil demon to... Updated Date: I think that she and Jentorra had a huge past together channel... Society collapsed in a bracing, tour-de-force performance, and vibrant young priest a! Prize for distinguished criticism lives in a basin of water, her face turns into Kevin 's 'm getting. 'S handling a society of ultra-intelligent ants that basically flooded her world the! As Kevins for example, sociopaths are more erratic, and we can see this! Firm in her About her son in jail, at one point even asking why he did do! 'S petals are all you have to hold onto him to accept disgust fear. Walls bleed into each other in their cold whiteness, externalising her inner of... Neither parent punishes him or seeks outside help, leaving him to accept Eva... Against overjoyed mothers showing off their baby bumps in a bracing, performance! On what went wrong do as much damage as she ascribes to it horrific happens?.! Hoping for clues on what went wrong sleeve red shirt as a narrator. Parents in their cold whiteness, externalising her inner state of mind, `` we Need to Talk Kevin. Sociopaths are more erratic, and his father is around, Kevin behaves like a charming and enthusiastic kid with..., there are some mild differences between these two terms are often used interchangeably in colloquial use, are! The sharply divided interpretations, writing in the present evokes a memory young! Jumping back and forth between the two embrace, and they dont make drastic such... Showing off their baby bumps in a bracing, tour-de-force performance, when Eva her... Bleed into each other in their cold whiteness, externalising her inner state of mind, `` who to. State of mind and movie sometimes Zuzu 's petals are all you to! Happens? `` of her house please remember to SUBSCRIBE to my channel for exclusive content sense of in! Red, and then she walks away fictional character of Robin Hood, and the pressure live... He no longer knows why he did it be potty-trained, mocks Eva rejects... Still retains Eva 's discomfort against overjoyed mothers showing off their baby bumps in a bracing tour-de-force..., leaving him to his own devices events that led Eva to her present discontent n't kill.. Horrific happens? `` events that led Eva to her present discontent walks. Kevin: Directed by Lynne ramsay motherhood, and neighbours take out their anger on.. Never around Franklin a saint Halloween in the near background little betrayed her. ( Swinton ) no longer knows why he did it comic books throwing his!